7 Reasons Dieting Doesn't Work for Most People ...

Laura

7 Reasons Dieting Doesn't Work for Most People ...
7 Reasons Dieting Doesn't Work for Most People ...

Dieting – it's a word that sends shivers down the spine, right? Let's face it, the quest for the perfect body has been haunting us since mirrors were invented. It's 2024, folks, and yet, dieting still seems like a mystical labyrinth where most people, including yours truly, get lost. So why exactly is it that dieting often feels like a never-ending loop of hope and disappointment?

Imagine the scene: You wake up committed to a new dietary regime, clutching a shiny book promising to transform you into the best version of yourself. Yet, by lunchtime, you're ogling your coworker's burger like a starved hyena. If you're nodding along, you're not alone. Dieting generally fails for myriad reasons, and while we could blame the cookies or the universe, let's dive deeper.

First off, does anyone else feel like counting calories is a mental equivalent of walking on a tightrope? I’ve been there, done that, and believe me, it’s not just about resisting temptation; it’s about understanding why a diet that works for your friend might turn you into a grumpy zombie. This brings us to our first point, individual differences in metabolism. Because, guess what? Our bodies are unique wonderlands.

And speaking of wonderlands, have you ever tried a trendy diet only to find out your motivation plummets faster than a rollercoaster ride? This is where the second point, psychological stress and depression, sneaks in. Trust me, I’ve tried turning down a slice of cheesecake after a rough day, and let’s just say, it’s a losing battle. Stress eating is scientifically backed and it's why we spiral out of control despite our best intentions.

On a funnier note, let’s discuss meal planning. I once followed a week-long meal planner that demanded ingredients seemingly sourced from Mars. After spending a small fortune, I ended eating cereal for dinner because who has the patience to prepare quinoa salad following back-to-back Zoom meetings? Hence, unsustainable meal planning deserves an honorable mention.

Another entertaining yet enlightening discovery is about food cravings. Trying to resist chocolate? It almost feels like chocolate has telepathic powers, beckoning you with an irresistible charm. Truthfully, this brings us to our fourth point, cravings and deprivation – where the battle of willpower almost always takes an expected nosedive.

Sprinkling in some humor during this diatribe lets us digest – see what I did there – the difficult reality of why dieting doesn’t work for most people. As we unravel more points, from social and cultural pressures to those infamous yo-yo diets, grab a snack, and let’s keep it entertainingly real. Buckle up, my friends, because while dieting might be a roll of the dice, understanding why it bails on us is definitely worth dissecting.

Snapshot Survey

What's your preferred social media platform?

1. You’re Too Busy

I have been through many diets in my lifetime. At the more ridiculous end of the scale was a juice diet, which lasted about half a day. Then on the more sensible end was Weight Watchers. Let’s just say I never want to hear the word ‘point’ again after that. Many are successful in the short-term, but one of the main reasons dieting doesn’t work for most people is that we are just too busy to permanently follow a regimen. The vast, vast majority of programs require continuous planning. Sometimes it is just nice to grab and go.

***

One of the biggest challenges to maintaining a successful diet is finding the time to plan and prepare meals. Many diets require you to plan out your meals and snacks in advance, and this can be difficult to do when you’re already busy with work, school, or other commitments. Additionally, it can be hard to find the time to exercise, which is an important part of any successful diet plan. Finally, it can be difficult to stick to a diet when you’re surrounded by unhealthy food options. Eating out or ordering takeout can be tempting when you’re short on time, but it can be difficult to make healthy choices when you’re pressed for time.

2. You May Eat More than is Necessary

I am by no means exaggerating when I say that actually paying attention to what I eat makes me put on more weight. This does make sense. While guidelines do have a lot of science behind them, they are not hard and fast rules we all have to live by. If you force yourself to eat every three hours, eat at certain times, or strike a ‘perfect’ balance, you may eat more than you need to. This is certainly true for me, and many other people I know. Instead of listening to a guideline, listen to your body. Eat slowly, pay attention to hunger cues, and you should meet your body’s needs based on instincts alone and maintain a good weight.

3. They Require Willpower, Not Lifestyle Changes

Diets require you to adhere to set rules, which requires significant willpower. For the majority of us, there is no ‘magic’ approach. The dieting industry is a multi-billion-dollar empire that makes us believe we need to live by someone else’s rules to succeed and be healthy. Guess what? We don’t! Rather than dieting, take a look at where you are going wrong. For me, this has always meant large portion sizes and grazing too much throughout the day. Instigate changes that work for you (slowly) and you will find the right balance.

4. You Deprive Yourself

I have noticed a sneaky pattern with diets. They trick us into believing they are amazing with these so-called two-week ‘induction’ phases. Usually these phases involve cutting out an entire food group. Sure, you will lose a lot of weight, but you will become downright miserable in the process. When you do come to the point where you slowly add in more food, you are highly likely to crash and put weight back on. Don’t deprive yourself of anything drastically; just be sensible.

5. You Don’t Address Your Emotions

Most of us overeat because of some emotion or another. If someone annoys me, I start munching. In contrast, if I am feeling loved up my stomach is in knots and I am like “Food? What the heck is that?” Start eating healthily by all means, but, make sure you start addressing how you respond to negative emotions too. Maybe, instead of eating A LOT when someone drags you down, eat a little of something amazing, do a little yoga, and see how you feel then. By addressing your emotions without the added stress of a strict diet, you can solve most of your overeating problems.

6. Eating is Pleasurable

Whoever said “Nothing tastes as good as thin feels” is absolutely wrong. When you eat something decadent or tasty, the reward centers in your brain go nuts for it. Guess what? That’s absolutely okay! Diets don’t allow us to have that enjoyable relationship with food. Here’s the thing: many of us don’t enjoy those sensations enough, because we don’t eat consciously. Rather than cutting out the foods you love, eat them consciously. The second they start to lose that “Wow this is amazing” taste, stop eating them. Make sure everything you eat that is decadent reaches its full potential without becoming aimless consumption and you will soon see some changes.

7. They Are Disempowering

The dieting industry is a world of snake oil and other magic potions. Marketers make you believe you need their drugs and supplements, then they sneak in the words “This works well with a healthy diet and exercise.” You don’t need these products, at all. It is YOU that does the work, not some obscure berry a marketer apparently sourced from deep in the Amazon. The same goes for fads, they don’t draw on your power. Learn how to control your food while still enjoying it, and you’ll soon see how great you are at controlling your own life!

Okay, so everyone knows someone’s sister/brother/aunt/whoever who ABSOLUTELY did lose 200lbs on Atkins and kept the weight off. That’s fantastic for them! Statistically, 95% of us will put weight back on after dieting. So become an anti-dieter, develop a great relationship with food, and enjoy life. If you are an anti-dieter too, how do you enjoy food as part of a healthy and fulfilling lifestyle?

Subscriber Specials

Feedback Junction

Where Thoughts and Opinions Converge

I just keep gaining weight these days!! Motivation is non existent! Any tips on how to get out of this frame of mind?! Help!! Feel like i have no time for anything but work...

I was watching a TED talk on this. You see, your brain has a normal set range of weight that it thinks it's normal. So I even if you lose weight, your brain will constantly try to make you gain it back. It will see your new weight loss as you starving, and so it will work hard to make you gain weight again.

I just wanted to express my sincere thanks for your wonderful content. Your eloquent and thought-provoking insights always inspire and resonate with me. Keep up the great work - I eagerly await your next piece! By the way, I would be very happy if you get a chance to check out my page! Professional steel foreign trader, lowest price, highest quality,

I'm trying to diet and it's so hard... like you need to cheat moe and then otherwise once you do eat carbs or what have you, your body won't break it down as easy because you haven't had it in so long . causing weight gain

I disagree with # 3,4,7 it depends on the individual and you can eat what ever you like moderation is key , and exercise is a good thing . Treat your body right and it will be good to you.

pleasurable eating is a huge key to having a healthy relationship with food for the rest of ur life. if u dont enjoy eating most of the time then ur probably overeating or u have some emotional bloackage towards enjoying the things that give pleasure to ur brain.

I eat everything in moderation (try to) I try and keep sweets to a minimum, no chocolate anymore cuz I stopped eating it for like 6 months and now it makes me sick like sick sick and thats bad for my heart. I'll have cookies and ice cream when the sweet tooth is there but there are other times when all I need is a sweet orange or an apple. And on weekends I don't limit myself. If I want mcdonalds thank you I will have mcdonalds and if I want noodles and company, hello! I found that depriving myself of anything led to me losing my mind and shoveling what I was deprived of into my mouth like I was dying in 12 minutes. The truth is, you workout, you eat right, you do countless numbers of sit ups and then you die. So while doing all that, what you eat needs to taste delicious. Otherwise you're gonna regret it on your death bed.

Related Topics

signs of bad diet worst coffee what causes hunger pangs yoyo dieting effects why see a dietitian beliefs about food just eat healthy how to choose a nutritionist how to cook oats diet makeover