2. Arctic Zero

If you really want to indulge and eat a whole pint of ice cream for yourself without eating over 400 calories, then Arctic Zero is your answer. One pint of this high protein ice cream is only 150 calories, contains no fat, and only has 6 grams of non-refined sugar. It has 14 grams of lean protein from non-GMO whey protein powder, no lactose, gluten or sugar alcohols, and it has 8 grams of fiber! It comes in amazing flavors like chocolate peanut butter, chocolate, vanilla, vanilla maple sugar, coffee, mint chocolate chip, strawberry, pumpkin spice, and cookies and cream! Still not convinced? It also has no artificial flavors or preservatives of any kind, but does contain organic cane sugar, so you’ll still want to watch how often you indulge. Per serving, which is ¼ a pint, it only has 5 grams of sugar. The brand also has 85 calorie bars for proper portion sizes, which would be the easiest option if you’re like me and have a hard time stopping with just one serving size! They also come in delicious flavors like vanilla, chocolate, strawberries and cream, and orange cream.